12 responses

  1. Mike
    March 20, 2026

    5 stars
    What douche leaves a low star rating for their own mistake???
    The recipe is 5 star.

    Reply

    • Kara Cook
      March 26, 2026

      Thanks Mike! Sadly, it’s so common that it doesn’t even surprise me any more. Thanks for making the potatoes and leaving a great review. I’m glad you loved them! 🙂

      Reply

  2. Cathy
    January 23, 2026

    5 stars
    I was looking for a recipe to help me use up some boiled potatoes, and I almost skipped past this one because of the low average rating. I’m so glad that I didn’t! (and I HATE it when people give a low star count because of their own stupidity! it’s like when you read a 1-star restaurant review and the person is mad because they were turned away from the restaurant because they didn’t have a reservation and the restaurant is full, but they never ate there… so aggravating!) These potatoes were DELICIOUS. So the only change for me is that I didn’t parboil them, since mine were already boiled (but just barely so, because I was using them originally for a raclette, and I had boiled them with a chicken bouillon cube so they had a little more flavor than just plain potatoes. They were red potatoes with the skin on, btw). To make up for them already being boiled, I used the fan oven to make sure they dried out well, and at 450°F they were ready in about 40 minutes, turning them halfway. I think your tip for heating the sheet pans is what really makes the difference! And I loved your comment about salting while cooking, I am going to take that to heart from now on.

    Reply

    • Kara Cook
      February 9, 2026

      Haha, yes, it is super frustrating when people leave a bad review because they made an error, or changed a recipe entirely! Glad to know that it worked with red potatoes, and that you found a great way to use the boiled potatoes you had on hand. And thanks for leaving a 5 star review, those are always appreciated! 🙂

      Reply

  3. Margaret
    January 8, 2026

    2 stars
    I would give this 5 stars if I had cut the cooking time in half, or lowered the oven temperature. Crispy was more like burnt. It’s my own fault for letting them go for 5 more minutes after I turned them at 22 minutes, but I was busy with other parts of the dinner.

    Reply

    • Kara Cook
      January 19, 2026

      It could be that you cut your potatoes thinner than mine, so they cooked faster. But that last few minutes does make a big difference in the crispness. If they were done, you could have just taken them out. I am a little confused as to why you gave them 2 stars when the only issue was that you baked them too long. 🙁

      Reply

  4. Toni
    April 24, 2023

    This is really a perfect side dish! A new staple at my house! Thank you so much!

    Reply

    • Kara Cook
      May 1, 2023

      You are so welcome! Glad you enjoyed one of my favorite sides. I could honestly just eat them as a meal, I love them so much. 😉

      Reply

  5. Allyson Reed Zea
    April 24, 2023

    These are so tasty and easy to make! Thank you for the easy recipe!

    Reply

    • Kara Cook
      April 24, 2023

      You are so welcome, glad you enjoyed them Allyson!

      Reply

  6. Amy Mayen
    February 28, 2013

    I’ve noticed the best recipes have the simplest ingredients! Yum.

    Reply

  7. Paulina Noyola
    February 28, 2013

    Oh those look yummy!! I have to try them!
    a homemaker’s journey

    Reply

4.50 from 6 votes (3 ratings without comment)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




Back to top
mobile desktop