Halloween Recipe: Bloodshot Eyeball Cookies

This post may contain affiliate links, which gives me a small percentage of the sale, at no cost to you. Thank you!

If you are in need of a quick and easy Halloween recipe that kids (especially boys) will love, you have to give these Bloodshot Eyeball Cookies a try.
Bloodshot Eyeball Halloween Cookies- only 4 ingredients!I was inspired by photos of eyeball cupcakes I saw in a magazine at the orthodontist’s office. But I wanted something less messy. Cupcakes tend to spread crumbs over half the planet. Or at least half my house. These eyeball cookies start with vanilla wafers, so less crumbs, and you don’t even have to do any baking. It doesn’t get much easier than that!
These simple cookies are perfect for Halloween parties!I love coming up with fun Halloween recipes. There are so many fun ideas out there! I’m not a big fan of the super creepy gross food. It has to actually look good for me to eat it. These eyeball cookies are creepy enough that my boys loved them, but not so creepy that I couldn’t look at them without gagging. 😉
Halloween recipe idea- Bloodshot Eyeball Cookies. Only 4 ingredients!
Eyeball Cookies- a quick and easy Halloween treat!One word of caution: it does take awhile for the red food coloring to dry, so I recommend making them a few hours ahead, or even overnight. Nobody wants red stained fingers, even if it is Halloween. haha
How to make Bloodshot Eyeball Cookies for Halloween

Yield: 7 dozen

Halloween Recipe: Bloodshot Eyeball Cookies

Halloween Recipe: Bloodshot Eyeball Cookies
Quick and easy Halloween eyeball cookies made with vanilla wafers and white chocolate.
Prep Time 1 hour
Total Time 1 hour


  • 1 box vanilla wafers
  • 2 bags white chocolate chips
  • 2 Tbsp shortening or oil (don't use butter or margarine!)
  • 1 small bag of M&M's
  • red food coloring


Combine the white chocolate chips and the shortening in a glass bowl. Microwave at half power, stirring every 30 seconds or so, until melted and smooth. Brush the crumbs off the Vanilla Wafers, then dip them into the melted chocolate with a fork. Tap off the excess chocolate, then place them on waxed paper. Place an M&M in the middle of each cookie. If your chocolate starts to thicken, just pop it in the microwave for a few seconds, then stir.

Let the chocolate totally set. Then take a toothpick and use red food coloring to draw the lines on the cookies. Tip: Place a drop of food coloring on a piece of waxed paper, and dip your toothpick in it. Wipe off the tip of the toothpick often, because chocolate starts to build up on it.

Let the cookies sit till the food coloring is totally dry.

Here are a few more of my family’s favorite Halloween recipes:
Halloween recipes from Creations by KaraBlack Cat Cookies/Monster Toes/Mummy Dogs


  1. These creepy eye cookies are perfect Kara! I totally agree about not liking treats that are so creepy that they spoil my appetite. These are the perfect combo of cute and creepy. I hope you are enjoying fall!! 🙂

Speak Your Mind