Homemade Butterfinger Ice Cream Recipe

Butterfinger Ice Cream – rich and creamy vanilla based ice cream filled with chunks of Butterfinger candy bars. A crowd pleasing ice cream recipe!

HOMEMADE ICE CREAM FOR THE WIN!

If I had to pick just one dessert that I had to eat for the rest of my life, it would probably be ice cream. Especially high quality ice cream from an ice cream shop, or even better – homemade ice cream! I’ve shared almost two dozen recipes, but I’m always up for trying a new one. 🙂

I actually tried this recipe a couple years ago at my cousin Tami’s house. Since it makes such a large batch, she likes to make it for family gatherings. She calls it butter brickle ice cream. Whatever you call it, it is absolutely incredible!

The base of the ice cream is so smooth and creamy it would be good on its own. But then you stir in pieces of butterfinger bars. Oh my. Every bite is creamy, crunchy, and just heavenly. 

When I have it at my cousin’s house, she likes to make it fresh and serve it soft serve, right out of the ice cream maker. People can’t get enough of it.

When I made it for my family, we ate some of it soft, but froze the leftovers. It’s just as tasty the next day, and the day after that! After you freeze it (or let it ripen) in the freezer for a few hours, it is nice and scoopable. Either way, it is sure to be a hit.

HOW TO MAKE HOMEMADE BUTTERFINGER ICE CREAM

(To skip my tips and just see the full recipe card, simply scroll to the bottom of the post.)

Ingredients needed:

• heavy cream (whipping cream will also work just fine)
• evaporated milk (adds rich flavor and creaminess to the ice cream)
• sweetened condensed milk (adds sweetness and creaminess)
• whole milk (I have also made it with 2% milk. I was the only one who could tell a difference.)
• vanilla instant pudding mix (Adds sweetness, flavor, and texture to the ice cream. Both vanilla and French vanilla are fine.)
• sugar 
• vanilla extract
• Butterfinger candy bars (You can use any size of candy bars, as long as they amount to about 10 ounces total.)

BUTTERFINGER PIECES: Basically the only thing that takes any time at all is breaking up the candy bars. We like a combination of finely crushed and large chunks. I pound half of them with a rolling pin while they are still in the wrapper. For the other half, I cut them into larger chunks on a cutting board.

My cousin actually breaks all of her candy bars into small pieces. You can do whatever your family likes!

ICE CREAM BASE: With sweetened condensed milk, pudding mix, and heavy cream, you know this ice cream is going to be the creamiest! Just whisk all of your ingredients together (except the butterfingers) till smooth. 

CHILL: The ice cream will freeze much faster if the mixture is very cold before you churn it. You can chill it for a couple hours, but overnight is great too.

CHURN: I have found that it works best to add the butterfinger pieces at the end of churning. If you add them too early, all of the larger chunks get smashed. 

I have a Cuisinart ice cream maker, and an extra freezer bowl, which I need for this recipe. If you have a smaller ice cream maker and no extra bowl, you will need to make this ice cream in two batches.

SOFT OR HARD SERVE: We actually love this ice cream recipe served soft, right out of the ice cream maker. But it is also tasty after a few hours in the freezer. 

LEFTOVERS – This recipe does make a large batch, so unless you are feeding a crowd, you will probably not finish it off in one sitting. It will keep in the freezer for up to a month if stored in an airtight container.

PRO TIPS

– To speed up the freezing process, chill your ingredients ahead of time. Yes, you can even chill the pudding mix, cans of milk, and candy bars.

-When storing leftover ice cream, press plastic wrap directly onto the surface before covering with a lid. This prevents the ice cream from getting an icy layer on it, and keeps it a little softer.

MORE RECIPES FOR HOMEMADE ICE CREAM:

• Milky Way Ice Cream
• Rocky Road Ice Cream
• Tin Roof Ice Cream
• Burnt Almond Fudge
• Chocolate Cookie Dough Ice Cream
• Blueberry Cheesecake Ice Cream
• No Churn White Chocolate Raspberry Ripple Ice Cream

RECIPES FEATURING BUTTERFINGERS:

• Frozen Butterfinger Pie
• Peanut Butter Butterfinger Cookies
• Butterfinger Trifle
• Chocolate Butterfinger Poke Cake

BUTTERFINGER ICE CREAM RECIPE

Homemade Butterfinger Ice Cream

Kara Cook

Extra creamy vanilla based ice cream loaded with chunks of broken up Butterfinger bars.

4.47 from 84 votes

Print Recipe Pin Recipe

Prep Time 10 minutes mins

Additional Time 4 hours hrs

Total Time 4 hours hrs 10 minutes mins

Course Dessert: Frozen

Cuisine American

Servings 16 servings

Calories 385 kcal

Equipment

• Ice Cream Scoop, Mint
• Cuisinart 1.5 Quart Ice Cream Maker
• Cuisinart 1-1/2-Quart Freezer Bowl

Ingredients

  

1x2x3x

• 1 pint heavy cream
• 1 12 oz can evaporated milk
• 1 14 oz can sweetened condensed milk
• 4 cups whole milk
• 1 3.4 oz box vanilla instant pudding
• ¾ cup sugar
• 4 Tablespoons vanilla extract
• 5 1.9 ounce Butterfinger Bars crushed

Instructions

 

• In a large bowl, whisk together cream, evaporated milk, sweetened condensed milk, whole milk, pudding mix, sugar, and vanilla.
• Cover and chill for 2-3 hours, or until very cold.
• Pour chilled mixture into an ice cream maker, and churn according to manufacturer's instructions.
• During the last 5 minutes of churning, add the crushed Butterfinger pieces.
• Serve immediately, or pour into an airtight container and freeze for two hours or more.
  

Notes

We like to reserve some of the butterfinger pieces to serve on top of the ice cream.

Nutrition

Serving: 1gCalories: 385kcalCarbohydrates: 46gProtein: 7gFat: 19gSaturated Fat: 12gPolyunsaturated Fat: 1gMonounsaturated Fat: 5gTrans Fat: 0.01gCholesterol: 56mgSodium: 167mgPotassium: 321mgFiber: 0.3gSugar: 42gVitamin A: 660IUVitamin C: 1mgCalcium: 235mgIron: 0.2mg

Keyword homemade butterfinger ice cream

Tried this recipe?Let us know how it was!